Citizenship For Adopted Children Canadas New Law For 2008
by Douglas Chalke,
published:
syndicated: 0 | total views: 4470 |
word count: 1645
laesbarhedsindex readability score: Difficult Readability
on the net: http://www.sunriseadoption.com
CANADA, Jan 21 — The impetus for Canada's new citizenship law for adopted children arises out of a 1998 Federal Court of Canada decision. (the McKenna case) That court found the different treatment of biological and adopted children in the citizenship law to be discriminatory and contrary to the Canadian Human Rights Act.
After several false starts Canada has finally passed new legislation to grant citizenship to children adopted abroad. The law will not grant "automatic citizenship"
T
he impetus for Canada's new citizenship law for adopted children arises out of a 1998 Federal Court of Canada decision. (the McKenna case) That court found the different treatment of biological and adopted children in the citizenship law to be discriminatory and contrary to the Canadian Human Rights Act.
After several false starts Canada has finally passed new legislation to grant citizenship to children adopted abroad. As a group, adopting parents are used to feeling "left out" or ignored. The Federal Government should be commended for addressing issues of importance to adopting parents.
There has been much fanfare about this new rule, and it is frequently referred to as "Automatic Citizenship". But is it really?
Numerous statements have created high expectations among adopting parents. For instance:
"This new legislation will enable Canadian families who adopt foreign-born children to apply for Canadian citizenship without having to go through the immigration process." (Immigration Lawyer website)
"A foreign-born adopted child would acquire Canadian citizenship as soon as the adoption is finalized, as long as the parents have applied for citizenship in the child's name before they leave home." (Official government statement)
I don't think either of these statements will prove to be correct.
Background
In order to understand how the new law fits into the overall process of obtaining citizenship for adopted children, it is helpful to look at the current process.
The immigration and adoption process requires prospective adopting parents to:
1. Complete a homestudy recommending them as adoptive parents for the child.
2. Prepare a dossier to be sent to the foreign country.
3. File an application to sponsor the child, as an immigrant, with Citizenship and Immigration Canada.
4. Obtain a Letter of No Objection or a Letter of Approval (depending on the country) from the provincial government or Hague Central Authority.
5. Sign a Medical Condition statement
After all these steps have been completed, Citizenship and Immigration Canada will issue a visa for the child to enter Canada as a permanent resident. The actual PR card is received by mail after the child arrives in Canada.
The final step is for the adopting parents to apply for Canadian citizenship by submitting the required evidence. Currently, this step takes several weeks. (In the recent past it had grown to a 30-month delay, but this bottleneck has been resolved). Once the child has Canadian citizenship, a Canadian Passport can then be applied for.
That is the basic immigration process (in some cases, it can get more complicated). In adoptions from Hague Convention countries an additional approval process is also required (not described here).
The New Law
Adopting parents come to the citizenship paperwork process near the end of a long process of preparing a ton of paperwork to complete homestudies and to send adoption dossiers overseas. None of that will change under the new law. Most of the steps described above will still be necessary.
At least one parent will have to be a Canadian citizen for the new law to apply. Permanent Residents of Canada who adopt internationally will not be able to use the new law.
The two steps that may be eliminated under the new procedures are the application for a Visa and the child's foreign immigration medical, but that will only happen in some cases (as detailed below).
The group of adopting parents who will be helped the most by the new law are expatriate Canadians living abroad who adopt overseas and have no intention of returning to Canada in the near future. Their child will be able to obtain Canadian citizenship by applying to the appropriate Canadian Embassy overseas. This group, however, represents less than 10% of Canadian adopting parents. What about the other 90%?
International adopting parents living in Canada fall into three groups depending on which country the child comes from:
1. Countries where the adoption is completed before the parents travel to pick up their child. Examples of this are Taiwan and Ethiopia. The new law should benefit in these situations. Any overseas delays in the child being granted Canadian Citizenship can be worked out before the parents travel. Any unexpected delays will be upsetting to parents but at least parents won't be waiting in a foreign country while the problems get resolved.
2. Countries where the adoption is completed while the parents are in the foreign country, and expect to bring their child home with them. Examples of this are Russia, Kazakhstan and China. It is hard to predict how the process will work in these cases. It depends how quickly the local Canadian Immigration office is able to process requests. What we do know is that if delays become common, parents will have the option of using the old system of applying for a visa and then obtaining citizenship after they return to Canada.
3. Countries where either:
* The adoption is completed in Canada after the child has been here for a period of time. Examples are Korea, Jamaica, Philippines and most U.S. States. Since there is no foreign adoption order, the new law will have no effect in these cases.
* The adoption is completed in the foreign country after the child has lived in Canada with the adopting parents for a period of time. Examples are Slovakia and Florida. The new law will not benefit these groups either. (There is however, a way to convert these applications to the new law - see USA section of the FAQs)
Other Issues
There are several parts of the new law, which may have a significant impact on the adoption process.
Immigration officers, before granting Canadian Citizenship, must be satisfied:
1. That the adoption is creating a true parent-child relationship and is not for some other purpose (This provision exists in the current law and is frequently used by immigration officers to prevent abuse of Canada's immigration process.)
2. Whether the adoption complies with the laws and rules of the country of origin. Sometimes, the answer to this question is easy to determine and sometimes very difficult. In these latter situations, it will clearly hold up issuance of citizenship.
3. That the adoption itself is in the best interest of the child. There is no question that the best interest of the child should be at the heart of every adoption, but is this the best time to try to make this determination? There may already be an adoption order in place by this time, and in many cases the parents will already be bonding with and caring for their child. The governments of many provinces already have a process in place to determine that an adoption is in the child's best interest. The Hague Convention procedures are also directed to determine just that issue. In a Hague Convention adoption, the Central Authority in the child's country of origin previously determines that (from that country's perspective) the adoption is in the child's best interest.
Will this process create a delay in the foreign country? A recent government analysis of these procedures published in the Canada Gazette states:
"Citizenship officers will verify that the adoption meets all of the criteria before granting Canadian citizenship to an adopted child".
Immigration Canada recently added a web page entitled Important Notice for Adoptive Parents which states:
"The Government of Canada is committed to protecting the rights of families and children. We have obligations under international Conventions to ensure children are not abducted, bought or sold, or removed from their biological families without their biological parents' legal consent. In some cases, extra steps in the citizenship process will be needed to make sure the adoption is truly in the child's best interest.
In order to be granted Canadian citizenship, a child must meet a number of requirements. The Citizenship Act and its Regulations specify that children must be protected when they are adopted from foreign countries. In certain countries lengthy investigations may be needed to determine a child's status. This can delay a child's entry into Canada. If a child is not found to be available for adoption, the application for Canadian citizenship will be refused."
This is not the language of "automatic citizenship". On the contrary this is the language of a government committed to living up to its responsibilities under international adoption conventions. The statement continues:
"There are instances where, following screening by the visa office, an application for citizenship may be denied where requirements under local law or international law are not met."
Determining whether all local and international laws' requirements have been met may not be a quick or easy process.
Lastly, if the overseas immigration officer decides not to grant citizenship, there is no appeal of that decision at all. Many groups objected to the lack of appeal process before the regulations were published but it fell on deaf ears. The right of appeal remains however in the Permanent Resident Visa process.
Conclusion
The new Citizenship law may not meet the high expectations adopting parents have for it. The law will not grant "automatic citizenship". Citizenship will be granted abroad if there is an adoption order in place before coming home and if the Immigration Officer is satisfied that certain requirements have been met.
Communicate directly with Douglas Chalke, the author of this article. Ask questions, send suggestions, comments, engage in conversation, or perhaps you would like to submit a project.
Click Here to ask a question, send a comment, or proposal.
Asian women command premium prices for egg donation in U.S
It’s technically called an egg "donation." But if you’re a young Asian woman, donating your eggs to an infertile couple can fetch enough cash to buy a use
Competition to get into good schools, colleges and universities seems to be getting more and more fierce these days. Pressure to perform well in exams has risen in a corresponding manner. More pressure inevitably raises the potential occu
In our modern days, parents will always appreciate any extra help. Parents who move around with their kids all the time should search a baby stroller travel system which can really help them.
We are all anxious for the arrival of the baby. Parents have prepared almost everything for that little special person that will complete their lives. But are they really prepared for the baby?
Organizing a home is something that you should carefully do to ensure that you get your most desired results. This is the main reason why you need to keep in mind a few essential factors once you start your home organization project. Here are a few o
A baby cot is a paramount thing for every nursery and if you are a very active parent and lead the life of a traveler in accordance with your personal desire or because your business involves much traveling, the best thing you can get for your little
First by reading this topic everyone will think that what is a cooking game?
Lets look at what a cooking game is. When a small girl is being given some toy
food items like banana, brinjal, tomato, grapes etc. the child starts playing.
But, when
On the Internet there are many free cooking games for kids, but are they as fun as the real thing? It doesn’t matter if you have children that are fussy eaters or if your children will eat just about anything that is in front of them, cooking is some
New to dress up games? Then you absolutely must play more until you’re an old pro. As a beginner, a list of essential games might be just the thing to point you in the right (most enjoyable) direction.
Christmas is a harbinger of prosperity, joy, and togetherness. It’s a festive time to adorn a house, a yard or surroundings. People celebrate the occasion with great enthusiasm all over the world in different modes. The concept
Barb and Maxine work for a large corporation whose profit for the last quarter was $400 million. Both women are new moms, currently at home caring for their children. Barb will be at home for 52 weeks and will receive 85% of her regular salary. Maxin
Prior to the earthquake in Haiti that country had many orphans, estimated by various sources as between 50,000 and 380,000. Since the tragedy in January the number has increased, but no one knows yet by how many thousands. The CBC estimates the
What does the future of international adoption hold for children and adopting parents? There are disturbing signs that the world is turning away from intercountry adoptions as a method of family formation. From a political standpoint, many
With all the new rules which Canada and the US Homeland Security have been creating about crossing the border it is getting confusing for adopting parents (including as of June 1, 2009, the Western Hemisphere Travel Initiative). In an attempt to clar
With advances in computer technology and DNA science, it seemed likely that a way would be found for the far-flung children of China to find their birth families. That day seemed far off in the future. However that day
Syndication
tweet
PDF version
Printable version
Publisher HTML version
Discussions (0)
Email Article
Post New Comment